Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Tax-free ? This was a regular Google team.


In the US, R&D expenses can often be deducted when filing taxes. I’m sure large companies like Google would be taking advantage of those rules.


Can't all expenses be deducted when filing taxes? I mean, taxes are paid on profit, which is revenue minus expenses.


Yeah the person you are replying to was imprecise - there's actually tax credits for R&D expense in the US rather than just tax deductions.

https://www.plantemoran.com/explore-our-thinking/insight/202...


Starting this year you need to amortize the R&D expenses over 5+ years, which is going to be brutal for startups.

Losing a lot of money and you can't write off your engineers


Not to mention the thing about tax credits, but when people say "R&D expenses" they often include quite a lot of investments on their definition.

In fact, it's arguable if anything in R&D qualifies as an expense at all.


Only money spent that turns into an asset is investment. I’m not sure how it is in US, but in Germany, for example, not even registering a patent is an investment and does not imply the creation of an asset — only buying the patent creates the asset.


What they meant was that the R&D was fully deductible, not amortized over a number of years. It's like saying that a business's electricity bill is "tax-free" because they can deduct it from their revenues immediately.

And as it is, Google certainly paid property taxes immediately on the office building as well as FICA on all of the employees who, of course, paid their own taxes.

But haters of the R&D system love to call it "tax-free".


There's the benefit of expensing the costs over amortizating them - but there's also straight up cash in the form of R&D tax credits - it's one method tech companies use to minimize their tax bills:

https://www.plantemoran.com/explore-our-thinking/insight/202...


Maybe they meant revenue free?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: