Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Anyone know what the persistent design flaw is? (Or are dehumidifiers intrinsically a fire risk for some reason?)


I think the primary design flaw is that they're built by the cheapest race-to-the-bottom manufacturer that cuts corners whenever possible. Advice like "make sure to only buy a quality one" may be useless if all of the quality manufacturers exited the business decades ago, unable to compete with the cheap flammable garbage that people were actually buying. Note how many formerly reputable brand names are on this list. The companies are hollow shells of their former selves, all buying the same cut rate hardware from some no-name overseas manufacturer and slapping their plastic over it.


There are some reliable manufactures, but the cost is significantly different. I had someone come out and give me a quote for an AprilAire dehumidifier system. The dehumidifier was $2,000, plus $1,000 installation. But they also needed an electrician to expand our circuit breaker.

I ended up going to Home Depot and buying a well-reviewed GE dehumidifier with a pump. Luckily it's not on this list. I'd rather have the AprilAire system, but $5,000 vs $400 was too much of a difference. I could replace the cheap one every a year for over a decade for the same price.


The problem is not just cost, it’s how do I know that this more expensive device is better made


> Or are dehumidifiers intrinsically a fire risk for some reason?

A dehumidifier has the same guts as an air conditioner, because an air conditioner was an invented by directing air over a dehumidifier [1]. So, it's not related to the "dehumidifierness" of it.

It's almost certainly the same factory, in China, sourcing the same faulty components.

[1] https://www.sunsethc.com/press-releases/the-astonishing-hist...


Likely a lack of thermal shutoff switch; So if it runs too long, the compressor fails, or the working fluid loses pressure then the compressor doesn't shut off.


I wonder if there is a static issue if they make the space too dry?


Maybe, but most have cut offs for when the humidity gets to normal levels. Even if they don't have that, they become less efficient at removing water when there is less in the air, so you would need a tiny space to get that low (the heat they produce would start a fire first)


unlikely.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: