Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Don't understand the hate for subscriptions. Some companies moved to subscriptions purely for a money grab, but for a lot of companies a subscription model makes more sense and a lot of them are really good value.

1password for example is only $3 USD a month. I don't understand why you would stop loving 1password because of a $3 subscription.



You want to build a stable system. Set it up so that the lower level pieces work and will continue working if untouched so you don't have to think about them and instead focus on the higher level stuff.

A software that is subscription based means your computer system seen as a whole will stop working at some point in the future if you don't remember to take a specific action (like updating the payment method or some such). It means uncertainty, it basically means you can only guarantee your system will work as-is for the next month. The more software of this kind you have, the more complex your system becomes to maintain in a given state and it burdens your mind.

I think it's fine for software you only intend to use for a few weeks/months at a time, or for software where you always want to be on the bleeding edge of tech, but for things as low level as a password manager? You want something really stable. It should also not update itself. So if we are not interested in updates what's the point of paying monthly?


My main gripe with 1Password is that it used to be a great product. It worked well, was relatively fast and stayed out of the way.

All those things have gone in later versions though.

Now it's very laggy and keeps getting in the way of my browsing, and I have lost passwords for new websites just because the modal to create the entry would "freeze" although not completely - I could still press the cancel button which would then ... cancel the creation, but also delete the temporary password item.

This modal stops you from using anything else on the browser as well, so there's no way out of it.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2026 batch! Applications are open till May 4

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: