Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The models themselves aren't political. They're not right, left, green, fascist or anything. They're just explanations and successful predictions of some part of nature. Politics comes into play with funding and what to do with technology. But that isn't the science itself.


The models aren't political. That is true. But the models do not exist without humans generating them and interpreting them.

The idea that science is somehow apolitical is dangerous. It's no more true than the idea that journalism is apolitical.

You can try to take more of a metaperspective with both, but to assume politics doesn't enter into the endeavors is dishonest. In many ways the position that science is apolitical is itself political.


> The idea that science is somehow apolitical is dangerous. It's no more true than the idea that journalism is apolitical.

The alternative is propaganda, which we already see enough of with journalism, and has happened in science when the government dictates the science. Science and the news should be held to an objective standard independent of any political considerations, even though humans are fallible and have biases, including political views.

> In many ways the position that science is apolitical is itself political.

This is like saying that atheism is religious. If you say everything is X, and I tell you that Ys are not Xs, then your rebuttal that my statement is X is abusing language and conflating X with Y. I could turn around, "everything is political", to be, "everything is scientific", and then claim that your statements to the contrary are scientific. But that would be collapsing meaningful distinctions, and potentially violating the law of identity, since it doesn't make sense for all political things to be scientific.


> The models themselves aren't political.

It depends on what you are modelling. If you're modelling human populations and behavior, they may become loaded with extreme political assumptions embedded in the model; and not all of those will be wiped out by the scientific method.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: