Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

That doesn't clarify anything. What's a "premium" streaming app? Why doesn't (or didn't) Spotify, who publicly opposes the 30% cut, qualify?

No official source qualifies and the article you linked just guesses based on screenshots. It also tells you that Apple does take the 30% cut if you trick the user into not realizing there's an Apple tax.

The video I linked (I know, it's long) discusses limitations as decreed by Apple itself. There's another video on that channel with even more in-depth information from Apple. There's no offer to make a deal and become a "premium service". I'm sure these guys would love to get their app available on more platforms, providing more value than they already can with just smartphone apps.



Premium = Too large to be bullied by Apple


Or you know, the other pillar of anti-competitive business practices, if Apple still needs their goodwill in some other vertical of theirs.


Like selling their physical products on Amazon. Amazon famously would not allow the Apple TV to be sold on their site until after this deal was made.


https://www.theverge.com/2020/4/1/21203630/apple-amazon-prim...

"The requirement: those platforms must be able to integrate core Apple services, apps, and features — including AirPlay 2, universal search and Siri support, and single or zero sign-on, among others."


I can't speak for or stand up for Apple here. I'm just posting examples of how/when Apple doesn't take their standard cut.


"It is only for individual purchases, and not for subscriptions."

Spotify is a subscription service.

To be honest I don't understand the rationale here - the criteria seem somewhat arbitrary - but I don't think Apple is being inconsistent in applying the criteria.


It’s not an “Apple Tax.” Developers get something of value for that percentage.


I get stuff of value for my state and federal taxes, too. They're mandatory and there's significant punishment for non-payment - hard to argue they're not taxes.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: