Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Sure, it's not like a Musk company ever broke the mold before.

Well to be fair they really haven't much, as far as technological advancements are concerned.

Reusable rockets weren't used before not because we didn't know how to do it, but because it doesn't seem to be economical. The judge is still out on whether SpaceX will actually be able to reuse the first stages in a way that's even remotely useful.

And there's even less innovation involved in Tesla cars. The only new thing they bring to the table is Autopilot, which arguably is a huge accomplishment, but not one that's "breaking the mold" in the hypercompetitive autonomous car space right now, and hasn't really delivered on its promises either.

What Neuralink proposes is so far ahead in terms of what we even glimpse to be technologically possible I have trouble thinking it's not basically his pet project that is guaranteed to receive press and funding just because the topic is sexy and it has Musk's name of it. If we are ever to get as far as NL implies, it will take more than a single consumer electronics company.

tl;dr I'll believe it when I see it.



People who are not impressed by the innovations of Musk’s companies generally aren’t involved in those fields.

I had a NASA fellow (guidance, navigation, etc, so a relevant field) who literally told me landing on a barge is impossible, just months before they accomplished it.

I personally think this will take decades. And the implications of it for humanity if it works are probably greater than anything else Elon is working on.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: