Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Congratulations, Uber, you just reinvented the bus.


But the vehicle's route is chosen by exactly-known demand rather than following a centrally-set and inflexible schedule and route. It's not much like a bus at all in actual practice.


I've never seen a bus that dynamically picks a point-to-point route based on the needs of the passengers on it at the moment.


They're very popular in a lot of places that aren't the USA (and even exist in NYC):

Dolmuş in Turkey: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dolmu%C5%9F

NYC "Shadow Transit": http://projects.newyorker.com/story/nyc-dollar-vans/

More broadly, "Share Taxis": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Share_taxi

The idea isn't anything new, but being able to pay and ride from the convenience of Uber is nice.


I think it becomes something different and much more efficient with enough data and good algorithms.


It's worth noting that the ones in NYC are illegal. With that said I'm all for moving mass transit in this direction.


They are illegal to street-hail— but this is unenforced. The city is working on normalizing them, including adding taxi-like branding: http://www.nyc.gov/html/tlc/html/industry/vans.shtml



Most private buses in the third world will do this.


For the passengers who are onboard, sure, but what about pickups?


Call their cell. It's written on the bus.


It's exactly how taxis work in St. Thomas.


The blog post cites the prior practice of informal carpooling with strangers; it is somewhat dishonest to insinuate that they claimed to invent anything.


Not quite. More like the shared taxi stops that operate in poorer countries. I saw many of these in Cuba. Not like a bus in that it was:

  1. Faster
  2. Carried fewer people
  3. Had route flexibility. You could pay extra to go off the route, negotiated with the driver and checking it didn't inconvenience the other passengers.
This is radically different from how we run transport in North America.

With self driving cars, I could see Uber running shuttles around the city that decided optimal multi-user routes taking into consideration all the various route requests users had entered.

I always figured this was their end game as far as consumer transport was concerned.


Hmm yeah, this kind of technology combined with vehicles that can carry large numbers of people could be very effective. Not quite the same as a bus, significantly better in fact.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: